In New York City, there’s a restaurant with allegedly sordid and unfortunate beginnings. One if by Land, Two if by Sea is a modern, upscale establishment located in West Village. There, one can find not only some of the finest dining in New York City but also some of the most notorious spooks in the Big Apple, too.

It is widely believed that One if by Land, Two if by Sea is haunted. Built in 1767, the restaurant was once Aaron Burr's carriage house. Burr is best known in history as the third vice president of the United States. In the 1790s, after the death of his wife, Burr took up residence there with his daughter Theodosia. Disturbing rumors of an intimate relationship between Burr and Theodosia allegedly fueled a famous duel between Burr and Alexander Hamilton on July 11, 1804, which left Hamilton dead and Burr in political ruin.

In 1813, Theodosia boarded a ship bound for Charleston, South Carolina. The ship departed New York City but never reached its destination port. It was never seen again. Later, in 1836, Burr died from a stroke in financial ruin.

Over the years, the carriage house changed hands and purposes many times. In 1973, it was refurbished and opened its doors as the One if by Land, Two if by Sea restaurant. The eatery may boast excellent reviews, but it’s the spirits we’re interested in. One if by Land, Two if by Sea is allegedly haunted by at least twenty different ghosts that terrorize the diners and staff. A maître d' once resigned after claiming he was shoved up and down the stairs each night by 'invisible hands.' Other reported paranormal events include flickering lights, disappearing and falling paintings, and diners being shoved by spirits. However, Aaron Burr and Theodosia are the most famous ghosts said to haunt the restaurant. Burr allegedly throws and breaks plates, while Theodosia reportedly walks the halls and steals earrings from unsuspecting female diners.

So, if you’re looking for a good meal that comes with a side of shiver down your spine, it seems that One if by Land, Two if by Sea might just be your cup of tea. Bon appétit!